A practical UK guide to using a performance improvement plan template fairly and consistently in a small business, including what to include, common mistakes, and when to seek HR support.

A PIP is a simple written plan that sets out the performance concerns, the standards expected, the support being offered, and the review dates. It is usually used when an employee is not meeting the required level in their role, but the issue is about performance rather than misconduct.
It should be used as part of a fair management process, not as a box-ticking exercise. If someone is repeatedly missing targets, struggling with quality, or not meeting core duties, a PIP can create structure and clarity. If the issue is conduct, attendance or behaviour, a different process may be more appropriate. If you are unsure where the boundary sits, it can help to read a practical guide such as disciplinary steps for small businesses alongside your performance process.
For employers dealing with a mix of absence, capability and performance concerns, it is worth separating each issue properly. That avoids confusion and helps you keep the process fair.
A good UK PIP template should be simple enough to use, but detailed enough to keep everyone aligned. The aim is to explain what is not working, what success looks like, what support will be provided, and when progress will be reviewed.
The document should be written in plain English and reflect the employee’s role, grade and responsibilities. It should be tailored to the situation rather than copied and pasted from a generic form. This matters because the clearer the expectations, the easier it is to review progress consistently and avoid misunderstandings.
The most useful PIP documents are very clear on the exact performance concerns. For example, instead of saying someone has a 'poor attitude', spell out the behaviours or results you are seeing, such as missing deadlines, repeated errors, or not following agreed processes. Specific examples make the conversation more objective.
Goals should be realistic and measurable. In a small business, that may mean improving response times, reducing errors, completing tasks to the right standard, or meeting agreed sales or service levels. Build in support too, such as coaching, check-ins, training, shadowing, or clearer priorities. If you need more help with day-to-day people issues, our employee relations support service is designed for employers who need a steady hand with difficult conversations.
Review dates matter because they keep the process moving and show that you are assessing progress properly. A PIP with no review point can quickly lose focus and become unfair to both sides.
Start with a conversation, not a form. Explain the concerns, listen to the employee’s view, and make sure they understand the standards expected. A PIP works best when it is part of a managed discussion, not a sudden email with a document attached.
Once the plan is agreed, keep notes of meetings, support offered, deadlines and any changes made. That record helps you stay consistent and makes it easier to show that the process was handled properly. It also helps if the employee later raises a grievance or disputes the outcome. If you want broader support across policies, meetings and documentation, explore our outsourced HR support for small businesses.
Be steady and supportive throughout the process. Small businesses often avoid direct conversations because they feel uncomfortable, but unclear feedback usually makes performance issues worse. A calm, structured approach is usually better for everyone involved, especially when you are trying to handle difficult employee behaviour professionally.
Below is a basic structure you can adapt for your own business. It is not a one-size-fits-all legal document, but it gives you a sensible starting point for handling underperformance in a practical way.
You can use the format below in a meeting and then follow up in writing. That way the employee hears the message clearly and also has a record of the expectations and dates.
One common mistake is using a PIP when the real issue has not been diagnosed properly. If performance problems are actually caused by workload, unclear priorities, absence, poor onboarding or a management issue, the plan will not solve the real problem. In those cases, a broader review may be needed, similar to the approach used in our guide to managing employee absence fairly in the UK.
Another mistake is setting goals that are too ambitious, too vague or impossible to measure. A PIP should stretch the employee, but it should not be unrealistic. Employers also get into trouble when they fail to keep notes, skip review meetings, or change the target partway through without explanation.
Finally, do not use a PIP as a disguised disciplinary step. If you already think dismissal may be likely, the process must still be handled carefully and fairly. A rushed or inconsistent approach can create avoidable risk and usually damages trust inside the team.
If performance does not improve after a fair PIP process, you may need to move to the next stage of your procedure. That could mean a further review, a more formal capability process, or in some cases dismissal for capability. The right route depends on the facts, the evidence and your internal policy.
Before any final decision, make sure you have followed a fair process, given reasonable support, and allowed the employee a chance to respond. In a small business, it is easy to move too quickly because the pressure is felt immediately, but acting too fast can create more problems later.
If the case is sensitive, senior, or not straightforward, get advice before you decide what happens next. Good documentation and consistent steps matter far more than making the process look formal.
If you do not have an internal HR team, performance issues can become time-consuming very quickly. You may need help drafting a fair PIP, planning the conversation, documenting the process, or deciding what to do if things do not improve. That is especially true when the employee is senior, protected by a sensitive issue, or already raising concerns about workload or management style.
Flora HR supports small businesses with practical, UK-focused HR advice that makes employee relations easier to manage. If you need help with underperformance, documentation or manager support, speak to our team through HR consultancy or get in touch for wider support with people issues.
A good PIP is not just a form. It is part of a fair, structured and well-communicated management process — and that is often easier to run with experienced HR support behind you.
No. A PIP is usually a performance management tool, not a disciplinary sanction. It should focus on improvement, support and clear expectations. That said, if performance does not improve, it may lead into a formal process depending on the situation and your policies.
There is no fixed rule, but many PIPs run for a few weeks to a few months depending on the role and the issue. The key is to set a timescale that gives the employee a fair chance to improve and includes review points along the way.
You can use the same basic structure, but the content should always be tailored. The performance concerns, goals, support and review dates should match the employee’s role and the specific issue you are addressing.
Listen to their concerns, check the examples and consider whether anything needs clarifying or adjusting. You do not need to agree on every point for the process to continue, but you should make sure the employee has had a chance to respond and understands the plan.

Shazia Khokhar
Founder, Flora HR
Need help navigating these changes for your business? Flora HR provides expert, hands-on HR support tailored to small and growing businesses across the UK.
Book a Free Consultation
A practical UK guide for SME owners and managers on when workplace mediation may help, the warning signs to look for, and when a different HR intervention is needed.

A practical UK guide for small business owners and managers on preparing for, handling, and following up on difficult employee conversations with confidence and fairness.

A practical UK guide for small businesses on employee absence management, with clear steps for reporting, records, return-to-work conversations, and spotting attendance patterns before they become bigger problems.

A plain-English guide for UK small businesses on spotting workplace conflict early, handling it fairly, and knowing when to use mediation or a formal process.

A practical UK-focused guide for small businesses on how to retain employees without overcomplicating the process. Learn the common reasons people leave, and the simple changes that can improve onboarding, management, pay reviews, flexibility, recognition, development, and HR processes.